Super Sale Alert: Products in this story may be marked down for Prime Big Deal Days. Shop our full coverage of the event here — or, dive directly into the deals here.

While buying a new mattress can feel overwhelming, we promise it doesn’t have to be a days-long process you have to agonize over. Sure, you want to consider your sleeping position, budget, and preferred firmness level, but once you figure out what you need, you don’t necessarily have to spend hours surfing every bed-in-a-box retailer out there. If you don’t already have your eyes on a brand, Amazon can actually be a great place to start your mattress search. And not only is it super convenient, with pages of Prime-eligible buys, it’s also a great place to save big. All our picks for mattresses are under $500 at the moment, and one even comes in at $149. And these affordable options still have a lot to offer —you can get a cooling mattress or a memory foam mattress or one ideal for most sleeping positions for around the cost of a new pair of designer jeans.

Keep on scrolling to see Amazon’s most popular sleeping options with near-perfect 4.0+ ratings, all with at least 5,000 customer reviews. We did all the hard work for you, you don’t even have to sleep on it to find the perfect one to add to cart.

Best Budget Mattress

Zinus 6 Inch Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress, $169

Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars and 150,361 reviews

This green-tea-infused mattress features one inch of pressure-relieving memory foam on top of five inches of high-density base support foam — perfect for back sleepers. Reviewers say they “would buy it again in a heartbeat” and that the mattress stays “just as comfortable as it was the first night.”

Best Medium-Support Memory Foam Mattress

Novilla 10-inch Gel Memory Foam Queen Mattress, $316.99

Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars rating and 28,199 reviews

Designed with gel-infused cooling memory foam and breathable bamboo fabric, this queen-sized mattress is not too hard and not too soft — perfect for the Goldilocks sleepers out there, or anyone who doesn’t want to commit to anything on either end of the spectrum. One happy customer explains that it’s “extremely comfortable, super easy to set up, and provides just the right amount of support where I need it most.”

Best Top-Rated Mattress

Olee Sleep 10-inch Aquarius Memory Foam Mattress, $244.17 $149

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars and 29,348 reviews

Say goodbye to sweaty wake-up calls, because the Olee Sleep mattress combines memory foam and cooling gel to help regulate your temperature all night long. Plus, its top layer is the perfect support to prevent any aches and pains. “The quality is amazing and the price is unbeatable,” one reviewer writes.

Best Mattress For All Sleep Positions

Sleep Innovations Marley 10 Inch Cooling Gel Memory Foam Mattress, $299.99 $239.99

Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars and 12,340 reviews

Featuring a triple-layer design with soft memory foam and a durable base layer for pressure-relieving support, sleepers will find support however they sleep, whether it’s on their side, back, or tummy — or tossing between all three. One reviewer explains that it’s “a PERFECT combination of soft and firm.”

Best Amazon Brand Mattress

Amazon Basics Medium FirmMemory Foam Mattress, $295.64 $200.16

Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars and 7,414 reviews

This memory foam mattress — which one reviewer says is a “super great mattress for a good price” — features three foam layers for optimal comfort and support: its first layer is the memory foam one with a medium-firm feel designed to provide support for any sleeping position; the second layer is a soft punched-foam one that offers breathability; and the third wavy hard foam base layer adds further airflow and stability.

Best Name Brand Mattress

Casper Sleep Element Queen Mattress, $595 $446.25

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars and 5,364 reviews

Designed to combine both softness and support, the Casper Sleep Element mattress features a top layer of memory foam that conforms to your body to relieve pressure, a perforated breathable foam layer that increases airflow for cooler temperatures, and a durable base layer that results in the “the best sleep” one reviewer has “ever had.”

At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff—and, while we do receive commission from Amazon, all of the goods linked to on our site are independently curated by our Most Wanted shopping team editors. All product details reflect the price and availability at the time of publication.